Undocumented or illegal aliens, if you will, do labor most legal citizens cannot or do not prefer to do. The jobs may involve uncomfortable conditions and pay relatively small wages.
If that labor supply is cut off, I believe the result will be a move to more mechanization in some cases, including robots and artificial intelligence, and a reduction in some types of production or services. And we’ll move on. Life will not come to a standstill. But we may well miss what we didn’t appreciate enough when we had it.
No, I’m no expert in these matters. I’m just a man in his 70s looking back.
Prunes, dried plums — we call prunes even when still plums in prune country where I grew up — back in the 1960s were still picked up by people crawling in the dirt of an orchard after the prunes had been knocked onto the ground by beating on the tree branches with long canes (in some cases picked off the tree).
I even did this as a kid, not so willingly, with my mom and one of my brothers. We did this to supplement the family income. But in those years there was a substantial number of poor white folks (and black and brown…) who depended on such work. They were migrant workers moving from region to region for the current harvest, prunes in California, followed by apples in Washington State, as an example.
But mechanization was making its appearance. The prunes in some orchards were knocked out of the trees by a machine that’s jaws were clamped on the trunk of a tree and shook it.
That was followed by an apparatus that set up a platform to catch the falling prunes. No more hand labor needed.
The prune supply was not cut off.
I think President Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society public welfare programs of the ’60s helped dry up the supply of citizen labor.
I recall seeing Mexican Bracero workers during harvest, a program that legally supplied labor from south of the border. I do understand the program was affected by corruption that cheated some workers.
At any rate, there are some crops that pose challenges to mechanization, but I doubt anything is immune. There are at least prototypes of machines or robots that can successfully pick tomatoes, the kind you buy to eat fresh. Those for soup and ketchup have long been mechanically harvested.
I’ve been commenting on agriculture because I seem to have been closely connected to it much of my life. But what about elsewhere?
Over the years of my life I think the kitchen staffs in cafes and restaurants became increasingly populated by foreign workers, large numbers of which were (are) undocumented.
Same reason, I imagine. Homegrown workers and their offspring moved on, thanks in part to social programs.
The result: combined with the phenomenon of the recent pandemic, many of our favorite eating spots disappeared.
Don’t get me going about the kiosk some places want you to use to order a fast food hamburger. I refuse to use them. Out of desperation, I tried one once. Never got my order. No one could or would help me, that is simply take my order and cook it.
And a kiosk and/ or robot to replace a waiter at a restaurant? I want to go back in time to the world of humans.
But, whatever, the cost of labor and immigration enforcement, and individual opportunity forces change in the workplace and our lifestyle.
This was obviously not a comprehensive address of the situation.
As a longhaul driver I sometimes have time to kill between loads.
My line of work will surely disappear over the coming decade or so, replaced by driverless vehicles. Some warehouses are replacing staff with nearly complete automation. Don’t ever say it can’t be done.
If there are things robots or automation can’t do like humans can, it’ll be done differently.
We adapt. Whether we’re better for it, I can’t say, or, not always, I fear.
—————————
Someone I knew and respected years ago opined that what we are now calling artificial intelligence or AI would NOT take over so-called thinking jobs. Turns out AI is now displacing white collar thinking jobs at a faster rate than blue collar.
In the name of progress, cost cutting, and efficiency, as a society we are making ourselves obsolete or dispensable.
Sent from AT&T Yahoo Mail on Android